Skip to Content Skip to Navigation

"New York" Pauly: Guestbook

security code

Angie Ward

June 26, 2016

6/25/16, Liz's Bachelorette Party!

Thanks for an awesome show!

Your show made our party!!

Allison Lawrence

June 24, 2016

Halfway there. Only 3 hours in the car left to go and we're back. First stop: my favorite spot - Irish Kevin's to see the one who does it best. Looking forward to a great week! -Your "favorite shrink". 😄

marc shipman

March 4, 2016

I have seen you about 6 times at Irish Kevin's and want to buy your album but cant. could you give me some insight on how i can purchase so music?


September 19, 2015

We had a blast the other night during our last night in key west! We were the girls with the GO SOX sign! :)

Nancy Salvatore-McNab

August 4, 2015

So now we're on our 11th year of coming to see you. As always, still great! Still fun! Still entertaining! Still always have a blast with you!
A trip to the keys would not be the same without you there.
I know that I can walk into Irish Kevin's to see you and forget about everything else going on in the world for a while.
Thank you for spending your birthday with us. And thank you as always for being so good at what you do. You're the best!!
Also, I would gladly accompany you on the cowbell anytime.
Xo. Nancy from Coral Springs

Eric Gonzalez

July 7, 2015

You made a bleh night into an AWESOME night! You rock!

Allison Lawrence

July 6, 2015

No one else can do it like you. ❤️

Hot bitch

July 3, 2015

Awesome show, can't wait to attend my next one...

Summer aka the Green eyed girl

June 23, 2015

Thanks for getting me up on stage for my 21st! Loved your show and can't wait to come back, Irish Kevin's is my new favorite bar on Duval!

Table 1

June 19, 2015

Caution explicit language: Fuck you douche bag! Your entertainment sucks. With love, table 1.


June 18, 2015

Love the website-- very individual pleasant and whole lots to see!

Paul (Pól MacDaibhéid)

May 28, 2015

Watch you a lot from Ireland on the webcam..
Really enjoy your show..
Cannot wait to see you in person next time in Key West.

May the Irish hills caress you.
May her lakes and rivers bless you.
May the luck of the Irish enfold you.
May the blessings of Saint Patrick behold you.

Irv Droste

January 20, 2015

You were f*#@ing great! One of the best entertainers I have ever seen. You know how to play the crowd with the best! As Billy Joel said "what are you doing in a place like this"


January 1, 2015

First time in key west, went to Irish Kevins Tuesday,it was so much fun, we decided to spend our NYE with you.

Ps. I chugged a guiness in 5.38seconds, that has to be the fastest girl time;)

Recently separated Mike

December 29, 2014

Went to Key West for anniversary, started the night out at Your show, after a few free drink coupons we ended up at suite of some people we met and I cheered my wife on giving oral to a room of bikers. Worst hangover ever now separated . Never going to Key West again.

Pamela Ryan

December 9, 2014

Thank you NY Pauly for a fantastic last night in Key Weat!!
I am the sister of the "douche bag" you kicked off the stage last night.
What a great time!! You are truly a fantastic entertainer..!!
Hope to see you again in the future..

Debbie Caiafa

December 8, 2014

Thanks Pauly for a great show..
I was the "douche bag" you kicked
Off the stage for just sipping the Guinnes
Beer. You are a riot! You are also an inspiration
To all that is possible in life!

Tracy Walker

November 7, 2014

First time in Key West and you were the best!


November 2, 2014

First time at Key West
Saw you Halloween - highlight of my trip!

Fred J Otterbein IV

October 8, 2014

enjoyed the 3xshows we saw - looking to get back asap. Not from NJ - from SC.

Chuck j

September 15, 2014

You made or trip better than great. You are a must see on all our future trips to Key West!

Boston Sean

September 12, 2014

Great act ! Go fuck yourself

Nancy Salvatore-Mcnab

August 25, 2014

So, just came back from yet another regular trip to key west to see you Pauly. It's been 10 years now-can't believe it. I got to see you 3 times this trip. Every night was absolutely perfect.
I don't know if everyone realizes how difficult it is to perform for four hours, get everyone involved and keep the overly drunk at bay while still managing to entertain all of us. I do.
On a Monday night when other bars had no one but the employees meandering around you had Irish Kevin's packed. So as always I thank you for being so good at what you do. You are very special and I can't wait to come back. And that's really saying something coming from someone born and raised in N.J. Xo. Nancy from Coral Springs


August 4, 2014

Great Time at Irish Kevin's, Thats one hell of a show you play.

Chris & Duane Leeper

June 2, 2014

Every time we go to Key West, we stop at Irish Kevin's to see you. LOVE your show and have such a great time! We are also from NY (Albany area). Thank you for giving us a fun filled night, can not wait to come down to Key West again and have a fantastic time at your show.


April 18, 2014

First time in key west I was told I HAVE to go to Irish Kevin's. Saw NY Pauly, what a great night with a great entertainer. Told everyone about how great he is and to go see him! NO SHIT

Anthony Q

March 18, 2014

Great time Thursday night, First time in Irish Kevin's and Key West... From Philly... No Shit

Rick wilkinson

March 8, 2014

Your show was great feb 24 and 25 enjoyed 1st night had to back for seconds

Dorene Hanson

October 19, 2013

My husband and I saw you for the first time last Tuesday the 25th I think but who can be sure, it's Key West! Just wandered in to a bar with a handful of people because we heard this amazing musician from out on the street. The music was great but as time went on the whole scene started to change. We stayed until the show ended, we were hooked. Thanks for a great night and we will tell everyone to stop by Irish Kevin's when in KW. We'll see ya next time. From 'not NJ'

Jeff Pelletier Olson

October 19, 2013

The first time I saw you perform at Irish Kevin's was in April of 2005 and I have been back about a dozen time since. You are a true entertainer and play at the best bar in the world! Keep it up! Cheers!

Rick Smith

September 28, 2013

Saw you last night at Irish Kevins. I'm the guy who tried to remind you of your "not you Akaida" comment from a year and a half ago. I sent you a photo of the guy laughing his ass off. Third time I've planned my Key West trip around your performance. You have a gift. God bless.

Valerie Parrott

September 2, 2013

Saw you in Key West on August 30, 2013! WE LOVE YOU!! Best act in Key West!!!!

Holly Hanna Heidi Erica & Your

June 10, 2013

Two years later and we're coming back!! Bringing a couple extra girls this time . . . Hope you remember us!

Clive Bruce

April 29, 2013

8 of us from the UK on a fishing trip to the Keys had a night out in KW. Were fortunate to drop into Irish Kev's at start of your show. Brilliant!!!!!!!!! PIRATES Yaaaarrgh.

Jan Hopkins

April 26, 2013

Was in KW recently and had a blast at your show! I want to do what you did...move to key west and never look back! I live in MI...and it was snowing yesterday. Nuff said! You ROCK!

angel & Lisa rodriguez

April 18, 2013

When we are in key west we always see your shows. Thanks for the entertainment.

Janie Griffin

March 18, 2013

NY Pauly, you're a total BLAST!!! So sad to leave Key West :( Had such a great time @ Irish Kevins with you!!! Rock on!!

Trish Yale

March 4, 2013

We just came back to Maine from Florida. Spent a night with Pauly at Irish Kevin's in Key West--what a blast!

Jack Hanna

March 3, 2013


Cathie and Jim Fox

February 9, 2013

NY Pauly at Irish Kevin's should be on your top 10 list of things to do and see while in Key West. His voice is amazing and he really gets the crowd singing and having a great time. One of the best shows in town!!!

Bob Bennett

January 12, 2013

Hey NY Pauly, you rock!!! We sang a different version of I wanna get lost in your rock & roll LOL. You signed my shirt and my wife chugged a guiness with you. What can I say, I am glad you got out of corporate america and decided to be you. You are electric with the crowd and anyone who vacations or lives in Key West and doesn't see your show is missing out on a life experience. Keep up the work and never change.

Greta Bennett

January 12, 2013

Never chugged Guiness before, and his entire act was phenomenal. Laughed so hard my ribs hurt the next day! Thanks for making our Key West experience the best vacation spot in America! You Rock!

Wayne Sorbelli

December 6, 2012

Hey NY Pauly - it's Wayne from Bone Island Music aka Island Guitar Key West!



October 7, 2012

Great new website!

Roly from Miami

July 28, 2012

Hey, Pauly!

Been a while, but we're finally going back to Key West. We're getting married down there on the 14th of August. Hopefully we'll get to see you perform. Would be great to sing some "La Bamba" on stage with you again.


Stu drew

July 21, 2012

Dude - made it to key west for the first time and stumbled upon Irish Kevins. I gotta say you f'ing rocked it and had so much fun. Hoping you bring the show to PA some time soon.

Thanks for the fun


June 15, 2012

Once again..... there is nothing to compare with what it feels like to be your mom and watch you "rock the house" time after time. You amaze me!!!!


May 7, 2012

Was just there for Cinco De Mayo! You rocked the house with a fun time for sure!
Brought a friend all the way from New Hampshire (NO SHIT!)


May 1, 2012

Youuu my friend are a fun time! Definitely loved the show..cracking up and singing the whole way through...had fun dancing to Wicked Game!
Lots of love from Maryland

Lauren suck my balls Daily

April 29, 2012

You have such a charismatic smile and you are by far my favorite live entertainer. I can not wait to see you work your magic again & again! The crowd absolutely adores your witty charm & Irish Kevin's is for sure extremely lucky to have such a devilishly handsome bloak (yah I googled the spelling) like you! SMB ;-)

Tiffany Castronovo Falta

April 19, 2012

It was great meeting u hope u can make it up to west palm one day to hang out with us girls again!


April 17, 2012

Thanks for letting me be the "Fair Young Maiden"!!! So much fun. Worth the trip from Toronto to see you! Am now in training for the Guinness Chug!! See you again! Cheers!

Tim n Kathy

April 14, 2012

You are the best! in the keys the last 2 super bowls, at Irish Kevins because of you!

Lee & Lisa

April 10, 2012

It was great to see you the other night. Best Barnicle Bill rendition I've heard in a long time Rhonda killed it.
Hope you make it up to Toronto.
Your buds from Canada,
Lee,Lisa Mark and Rhonda

marc & mary

March 29, 2012

March 23, 4th time in key-west and 4th time seeing NYP, took friends this time. Thank You for a f***en great time. YO-HO


March 12, 2012

Awesome performer! Had fun chatting sunday (3/11). Looking forward to visiting again! Hypothetcially... Hot tub hahaha


February 24, 2012

There are rumors and questions pooring in from all of Steve's fans and I'm sure N.Y. Pauly's fans are pounding him with the same questions. Well the rumors are true I will be stepping back into the corner of the stage for a serious Guinness chug one more time. My name will be back on that board! So ladies take youre birth control because you will need it after seeing me pound that Guinness in less than a minute. The training that I'm going thru at this time and up until the date of April 7 will have Stallone taking notes for use in the next Rockey movie. See you Fucktards in April.

Oh yeah New York Pauly rocks blah blah blah.

Cathie and Jim

February 19, 2012

Just got home from a 9 night stay in Key West and ready to plan our next one. NY Pauly is always top on our list of shows to see and we saw him several times on this trip. We had an awesome time as we do at all of his shows. He is truly a talented performer and gets the crowd engaged in his songs and playfulness. After all these years he got me (Cathie) on stage this time and I did have fun. If you want a great show, he should be a must see!!!


February 13, 2012

We saw your fantastic show at Irish Kevins last night Feb 12,2012. We had an amazing time and woke up with our faces hurting from the laughter. We were wondering where we could get the lyrics or the video of you singing Things you Don't Say to Your Wife,
Thanks for providing us with a night of great music, humor, and entertainment!


February 11, 2012

So, I really enjoy the comments in this guestbook. the support and feedback is important to me. *recently, people have told me that they have tried to post notes but were unable to bc of the security code!!? If you are cool enough to take the time to visit the site and try to post (unsuccessfully) pls let me know, either on Facebook: or email: Thx.

Tammy Zuback

January 31, 2012

great meeting you on flight to San Diego! I'm sure your gig at the hotel del Coranado will be spectacular! Will definitely look you up in Key West!


January 27, 2012


Joe becker

January 26, 2012

I saw NY Pauly on my first ever venture to Key West in January of 2006 and I have long wanted to come back. Love NY Pauly and his style of music!!

Beth Rooney

January 26, 2012

I had a blast at both of your shows last week!!!! You're act is hysterical and had me giggling the whole time. Thanks for sharing your NY with Key West even though you gave me the finger for being from Jersey!!!! xoxoxo!!! Good times!!!!

Shawn mack

January 24, 2012

spent a good portion of Jan 19th at Kevin's...1st - very close to closing I requested and you played Cocaine Blues - it was outstanding!!! Very tough to pry money outta my pocket but you did...

Molly - The Original Cowbell Girl

January 17, 2012

NYP - still checking in on my favorite friend/entertainer/PERSON in KW. I hope all is well as I'm confident it is -- I check in on you often via webcam, you motorboatin sonofabitch! Always - M


January 17, 2012

Sup ny well me and my fan were down there from th 10-17 of Dec and had a blast can't wait to come back

Kelly Dixon

January 12, 2012

You rock! We've been coming to Key West for as long as you've been performing there and you are by far our favorite entertainer! So glad we got to see you when we were down for the Ragnar Relay this weekend! Thanks for hanging out with our group and chatting and taking pictures with us! No trip to KW would be complete without a catching your show!!

Sharon & Ron

January 11, 2012

We are the parents of the bride and were lucky enough to spend time with you on
1/11/11 after the wedding. You were kind enough to have my daughter Sara and
her new husband Ed on stage with you and it was great fun ! Wishing you happiness
and the luck of the Irish - Always !!

Louie Louie (Hughes) that Harmonica Guy

January 11, 2012

I sure miss those days of playing at Irish Kevin's. Glad to know you are still keeping the Key West faith, Pauly! Stay healthy and jam on, friend!

sara & ed

January 10, 2012

Sure wish we were down there partying with you for our wedding anniversary tomorrow!!! Everyone from our wedding on 1-11-11 still talks about how great your show was, and Ed and I especially loved being on stage singing with you!! We will ne back...see you soon!!!


January 10, 2012

thx guys..i love hearing from you!


January 10, 2012

Reading the reviews of your shows makes me wonder when you will be discovered by a national audience and go on to even greater heights. Reviews are no exaggeration. You are the best.

Chicago Jen

January 10, 2012

Hi NY Pauly's Dad! :) Hey it was great to get a chance to talk to you some this last time down in Nov for the Power Boat races. Your shows were awesome as always and the first thing I do when I get to the island is check your schedule. You know I love ya!


January 10, 2012

WOW!! Great stuff Pauly!! I knew you would make it big!! Keep on rock'n!

Brandi and Matt

January 10, 2012

We were down for the RAGNAR race this weekend and didn't get to see you :( but when we saw you in August you were awesome! Can't wait to come back and see you again :)


January 10, 2012

Pauly - I got a fever, and the only prescription is more cowbell....and you of course!! :)
I've been coming to your shows for what?....6 years now...and it's always filled with deubauchery, trickery, raunchiness, most favorite things, but surely not for the faint of heart! But most importantly your shows are always hilarious and entertaining! Everytime I bring a friend from out of town to IK's they always gush about your show and can't wait to come back for more. NY Pauly, YOU are the reason I keep coming back to IK's time and time again.....shenanigans!!


January 10, 2012

Well its been years since we were in Key West but we will never forget the AWESOME time we had with NY Pauly when we were there! We had so much fun...even when they made me get on stage to sing Barnacle Bill! Thanks again for everything!

Steve and Kelly

January 7, 2012

We saw you twice this week at Irish Kevins. You were awesome! I got to do the Guinness chug contest, and the second time you brought Kelly on stage for her birthday. We had a fantastic time and will definitely come see you again when we return in September. What a great show! Thanks

hot chicks

November 27, 2011

" and my girlfriends just got back from key west where we saw the most amazing show ever! not only is ny pauly an amazing entertainer (so many awesome songs and so funny!!! lmao!) but he's also soooo freakin' sexy - he made us so wet, we were all sliding off our chairs!! if you're ever in the keys..this guy is a must see." ;)

Ron Sloman

November 6, 2011

Been enjoying your talent since you arrived. Never heard you play," Gimmie Three Steps" by Skynard. Guaranteed to lite em up just like "Sweet Alabanma". Fantasy Fest rocked. Will be back soon!!
"Sugar Daddy and Jail Bait"


August 19, 2011

I have great memories of seeing you the first time 5 years ago. My friend and I are coming down to celebrate our 30th Birthdays in October. Was wondering if you will be at Irish Kevins 10/24 through 10/31. Hope to see you.


August 18, 2011

I've been making the drive from Coral Springs, Fl to Key West just to see your show. After seeing you the first time years ago I was hooked. There are alot of people who can play a guitar or sing a song. That doesn't make them entertaining. The song choices are great, as is the interaction with everyone. Even though I'm origionally from N.J. I'm one of your biggest fans.


July 26, 2011

Love u, Pauly! Just saw ur show in Key West! Muah!

April Kountz

July 26, 2011

I saw your shows last week and thought you were awesome!!! One question though do you ever do shows here in the Dallas/Fort Worth area?

John Nichols

July 25, 2011

Best live entertainment Iv'e seen in years. Can't wait to head back.... Thanks for the Great Time and awsome show. It was nice speaking with you after the show.... You from New Jersey !! "FUCK YOU".

Trina Matthews

July 24, 2011

NY Pauly's show at Irish Kevin's was definitely the highlight of our week in Key West! We had a blast! Can't wait to see it again. NO SHIT!!! :)

Lauren, Erika & Friends

July 20, 2011

Thank you for being one of the highlights of our week long vacation to Key West!! We loved your show and of course, you!!

David & Tammy Ellison

July 6, 2011

Just wanted to thank you for taking time to speak with us after your show when we were there in Feb. 2011. Your show was a one of the highlights of our trip to Key West. We are enjoying listening to your CD out on the patio every weekend. Can't wait to listen to you in person when we are back in Key West next March!

Chris S

June 30, 2011

Hey just wanted to say thanks for making our duval crawl a shit ton better. ive been stationed in quite a few states and have never had this awesome of a time at any bar.

James O'Keefe

June 26, 2011

Really would love to get the live CD but have been checking Irish Kevs online for the last 3 months and NO CD. Unless your playing live in Western NY soon I wont be getting it. Any chance of finding somewhere??? Anybody know???

Matt & Makenna

June 20, 2011

Just saw you the 17th & 18th. You are the reason to go all the way down to Key West!!!
"If your hands are not up you are a fuckin douche" NY Pauly!!

Tammy and David

June 19, 2011

I am sure you don't remember the "old" couple that bought your "last" CD in February, but we loved you! Thank you so much for talking with us after your show. We listen to your CD every weekend (although we don't want to wear it out like we did the first one we bought a couple of years ago!) You are one of our great memories from our Key West trip. We will be back next year and hopefully will have the pleasure of seeing you again!


June 6, 2011

Home Sweet Home but still hearing your tunes in our heads......... thanks for the memories!

james burk

June 3, 2011


jamie crazyhair girl

May 22, 2011

you went above and beyond "entertaining" me this past wknd.. You are very trusting* Looking forward to the haircut. =)

Sara and Ed Skorak

May 17, 2011

We had an awesome time with you at Irish Kevins during our wedding in Key West on 1-11-11. We have lots of pics and videos of us on stage with you that night! You rocked the house, and I especially loved playing the cowbell during "Blister in the Sun"! LOL Sure hope to see you in Key West again soon!! (let me know if you want any pics!)

Pat Kelly

May 11, 2011

Had a great time in KW. Kept coming back to see youat Irish Kevins to see and listen to your music. You Rock.

Brian Severson

May 10, 2011

Yo NYP... Da Chi Town crew is back in KW... Lookin forward to seein u rock da house at Irish Kevins.... Peace and lookin to hear Sweet Home Chicago... and My kinda Town.... Later Hoss ....
Bezel and Da Crew

James O'Keefe

May 5, 2011

Loved your set at Kevs on Tues night. You fuckin rock!!!
Next Page >>