Skip to Content Skip to Navigation
Join the email list!

"New York" Pauly: Guestbook

Barbara

September 3, 2008

Great time Monday night on an otherwise slow Labor Day evening in Key West. You managed to fill Irish Kevins when other places were dead! However your claim that I was the one person who f''d up the clapping and thus ruined everyone's chance at a free beer paid for by you were incorrect! Then to give them all the impression that I would buy their round was so unfair. It's a shame you wouldn't let me use the funds from your tip bucket to pay for them all. The next time I visit Irish Kevin's I'll stop in and buy you a drink. Had the best time! You are a true performer. Keep em coming!

Tracy

September 2, 2008

Great show! Saw you on August 31st and September 1st during my birthday weekend. Thanks for the laughs! The "Brokeback Mountain" comment still has me laughing!

Amber

August 22, 2008

Hi Pauly! My hubby & I enjoyed you and KW so much for our honeymoon, we're coming back in Sept for our anniversary. We're planning on Kevin's to be our first stop! See you on Sept 6th.

Jeff Conway

August 17, 2008

You are a fucking lunatic man. Spent 2 nights @ Irish Kevins and you are by far the best entertainer in that town. Thank you for a blast of a good time and fuck that cunny and her fat man friend that 'bought' you that beer Saturday night.

Kim

August 14, 2008

Hey Pauly! I'm the squeaker girl from "Team A." You made our vacation an absolute blast! We came back the following night for more but to our disappointment no Pauly! We're driving home trying to recap the lyrics to all of your fun songs. CD's are ordered and cannot wait to get them. See ya next time!

RachMSU

August 10, 2008

We were walking down Duval Street last week and it seemed that the people in Irish Kevins were having a good time. We caught the last half of your show on Tuesday - great times!!! Team A kicked Butt!! It was so good we wandered back in on Thursday even though we were leaving 6am Friday morning. Thanks for the great entertainment and for bringing in more cow bell. We sang that song all the way home to Michigan!!

Sarah Jane

August 4, 2008

Loved having you at McGrath's.. One of the best times I've ever had there! :) Make sure you come back for another show!

STEVE FROM ALABAMA

July 19, 2008

WHATS UP DUESCH. BACK IN ALABAMA AND PLANNING MY NEXT TRIP BACK TO KEY WEST. YOU KICKED ASS, THANKS FOR A GOOD VACATION.
P.S. HOW DOES A GUY WHO LIVES IN PARADISE HAVE SUCH WHITE PASTY SKIN? AND WHEN DID DEAN GET A SECOND JOB AS A SINGING PENIS.
GOOD TIMES.

Brutellio

July 13, 2008

Hello. I enjoyed reading your website.
Have a wonderful day and keep up the good work.
Brutellio.

Sheri and Marc

July 11, 2008

We try to get to Key West once every couple months, just to see you! My boyfriend just asked me to marry him, and my first response was CAN WE HAVE PAULY AT OUR WEDDING!!! We will also be up again to celebrate, so I can be "another dumb bitch getting married" ;-) I purchased your CD and we love it! Keep Rockin Key West!

Greg & Debbie Talley

July 11, 2008

Pauly
We had a greeat time this last April at your show. Just found your site by doing the youtube thing. By the way we did your barnacle bill songs for some friends the other night at a party and they about shit! Keep up the good work and we'll see you again next spring. Unless one of us gets hit by a bus.
Take it easy.

Molly - Cowebell Girl ;-)

July 7, 2008

Pauly! Thanks for such a great time at Irish Kevins. You have the best show in Key West ... and it doesn't hurt that you're smokin' hot! I listened to your CD on my commute to work this morning and laughed the whole way when I would have normally been stressed and annoyed with traffic. Thanks again for everything - and especially coming to rescue us on our last day! Miss you tons - see you soon ... Keep rockin out to Sweet Home Alabama ... ha ha ha Oh ... and think about those songs I talked to you about ... total panty dropper.

Sherri, Greg, Ken, & "Mom"

July 1, 2008

Hey Pauly, WE LOVE YOU!! Thanks for an AWESOME SHOW on Monday night- we had a ball :-) You totally rocked on "Ice Cream Man" and everything else too!

Thanks for playing dirty songs for my Ma! :-) See you again next year!

Anthony

June 17, 2008

Was at Irish Kevins for you show this weekend. Didn't think the 80 year old you put on stage to do "Blister in the Sun" could hack it but she did... YOU SHOULD HAVE MOTORBOATED HER!!!!

KK

June 15, 2008

Hey, we were in Key West this past April, just found your site. Love, loved your show!!!!! Just one suggestion, no more motor boating! And hug your grandma!
YOU ROCK!

tara & steve

May 27, 2008

hey pauly - thanks for a great week. you helped make our anniversary really fun and memorable. hope all goes well on your trip to ny - let us know how it turns out. hope to see you again very, very soon. big hugs from DC!!

Sue~

May 26, 2008

Imitated never duplicated!

Mike Cameron

May 12, 2008

Thanks Again Great Fuckin Show!!

Kristie Lanehart

April 24, 2008

I was in Key west April 16-21 2008 and loved listening to "new york" pauly. He is one of the funnest and funniest people to watch and listen to! We had a great time at Irish Kevins. We will definitly be back to see him play.
-Kristie

ED CARTER

April 20, 2008

Hey Bro,
since we talked and i heard u sing, i plan on
getting my ass down to see New Yorks fav son, see u and Dean very soon.. LETS GO METS

The Foxes From Michigan

April 18, 2008

Hey Pauly,
Loved your shows last week, as always, you're the best show in town! Don't think there's anything you can't sing or play, you're truly an
awesome performer. Keep enjoying what you do, so we can too. See ya in the Fall.

Alison

April 15, 2008

Hey Sexy! You are the shit and I think I am in love. You really now how to entertain and take care of two innocent women from Wisonsin! Thanks so much for everything....

Lindsay Brennan

April 15, 2008

Hey hey hey!
You made my trip to Key West. =) Thanks for showing my sister and new brother in law such a great time! And I wasn't fuckin' around about playing my wedding. =) I'll be in touch.

Ricci Bobby

April 9, 2008

You have mastered the art of captivation and entertainment. I was very impressed in so many ways by your performance. You have a awesome sense of humor, a great personality, and have made my stay inthe Keys very memorable! I hope we meet again...

The IBTC

April 9, 2008

Great show, Pauly. It's just too bad you didn't have "Hot for Teacher" ready to go.

However, Ms. Leonard's application to the IBTC has been rejected on the grounds that she was being way too modest and clearly way exceeded the criteria for membership.

Ms. Leonard

April 7, 2008

What a memorable experience I had at Irish Kevin's! You are great in so many ways.. An extremely talented performer, hysterically funny, and an amazing person. I can't wait to come back to Key West and see you again!!!!!!

PIRATE STEVE FROM ALABAMA

April 2, 2008

WHAT UP. THREE MORE MONTHS AND I'LL BE CLOSING DOWN IRISH KEVINS EVERY NIGHT FOR A WEEK. YOU BETTER NOT BE OFF JULY 11 THRU 16. THERS A HUNDRED DOLLAR BILL IN YOUR TIP JAR IF YOU RIG THE GUINESS CONTEST SO I HOLD THE RECORD. LATER DEUSCH BAG.

UCF girls

March 20, 2008

pauly, you are so effin' hot! we looked forward to seeing your sexy ass every night when we were in kw on spring break! we all love you and want to have your babies ;)

Mom

February 22, 2008

Have I told you lately that I love you? When are they moving Irish Kevin's to New York? You live way to far away! Sooooooo proud of you,tho!

Amber Letteer

February 22, 2008

Pauly, we saw you perform last September while on our honeymoon and you quickly became our fav memory of the week. We purchased your cd and listen to it often to bring the memories back. Thanks and come to Charlotte, NC!!!!

Allison

February 21, 2008

Had a great time Saturday Feb 16th!! You were great as always! And we bought your CD the very next day! As our 2nd time going to Irish Kevins, it's always a blast when you are there!

download mp3 cheap songs

February 21, 2008

mp3sonik.com

Rock 'N Roly from Miami

February 10, 2008

Yooo Pauly!

It's Roly from Miami. Just letting you know we'll be down there the weekend of February 23rd. My friends and I are gonna attempt the Duval Crawl this year and Irish Kevins is definately on our list. Hope to see you there!!!

-La Bamba Guy.

Ruth & Billy Rhodes

January 22, 2008

Pauly,
Hey dude, we are the couple that came up to you at the Big Head Todd and the Monsters show in Ft. Lauderdale. Ruth was a little intoxicated but now that she saw your website she remembers you. We'll be down there in a couple months. Take care man and keep'em laughin!!!

Later,

BR

Fair Young Maiden

January 17, 2008

I don't know who was better, you or SPONGEBOB! I gotta hand it to you though. You're a blast! I showed up twice and would have liked to see you again before returning to Boston, but didn't have the time. Irish Kevin's is my favorite Key West bar, and you guys entertaining us make it what it is. Keep up the awesome work. We wouldn't have had as much fun without seeing you! I'll shoot for a 3rd time on stage with you when I return! ~Amy~

The Jimmy

January 8, 2008

Dude, you were a ton of fun, and a hell of a good musician. I came down to the Keys for the first time for New Year's Eve. We hung out with you on Thursday the 3rd of January. We were all bumbed because it was our last night, and the weather turned to crap, didn't want to go home, blah-blah-blah. But you were AWESOME. You had my friends up on stage singing and chugging beers. I was the jackass that asked you to place some DOORS. You nailed it. Have a good winter in paradise brother, we'll be back to raise more hell later in '08. Thanks again!!

Steve Campbell

December 16, 2007

What up Pauly, It's Steve from Alabama just wanted to say thanks for an awesome week. We plan our whole vacation every year around coming to watch you play and you never disapoint. See you next year, GOOD TIMES.

George Duffield

November 28, 2007

me and my wife had the best time watching you and i can wait for you to come out with another cd. Thanks for making our trip to the keys a blast!

Keith Page

November 27, 2007

Pauly you are a god I lived in the Keys for a year and come see you get Irish Kevins hopping every time I could...I especially loved coming on stage for the Guiness chug (my personal best was 2.7 sec) and would get up there evrytime you invited your fans on stage with you (you prolly wont remember but I was the short white kid who could put it down, just not for very long) hope to get down to the keys and away from my now corporate job soon and stop in and have more then a few beers...Cheers!!!

Joseph

November 27, 2007

Hey Pauly I got on stage and sang with you on my twenty first b-day i was so smashed i couldnt remember the words to "Sweet Home Alabama" lol great times at the best Bar in the States! CHEERS!

Burt Jamison (you always call me Hemingway)

November 27, 2007

great site, you are by far the best there. Have not seen you since Oct. 23, 2006, when Irish Mike got up on stage between the motor boatin... Looking forward to hearing you play soon, Cheers, Burt

MariLeapetercarty

November 26, 2007

Hello, I was just searching blogs, and found your site, friend! I like it! ... . - . , . Regards

JamesCooks

November 24, 2007

Nice.
Keep up the great work.

Tab

November 4, 2007

Can't wait to see you this weekend!!!:)

randy

November 3, 2007

whats up pauly? where the fuck are my wedding pictures? you have to put them back up. you were the start of a happy marriage, you should be proud of that

your constant admirer

October 31, 2007

Your show gets better and better! Keep up the great work.

Ed carter

October 9, 2007

Well brother, as usual your shows were great and cant wait to see u "ROCK THE HOUSE AGAIN" again in dec. Stop letting Dean have so much time off.

Jim

October 7, 2007

Still the best show in the Keys. We came, sang, drank and she doesn't remember

Melissa

September 25, 2007

hahahahaha, it was blast this weekend. Thanks for bringing me to the stage! I'm sure our show will appear on you tube soon! hahahaha

Kelly & Gregg Dixon

September 23, 2007

We love you and don't ever miss you when we come to Key West!

Bobbiestyle

September 11, 2007

Your show rocks. I tried Barnicle Bill for real. IT WORKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She liked it, She really, really like it. And she even cleaned up the spot that missed her $#@*. keep on rockin.

Bad Kitty

September 8, 2007

Good times!!! You were a highlight of our vacation (and sure made my husband proud...."THAT'S MY WIFE!")
See you next year...Cheers!

Sean P

August 21, 2007

Came to Key West as part of a road trip down the east Coast, and your show was the highlight. My friend i was with is English but he even bought an Irish Kevins shirt just to remember! Best bar ever. Yo Ho Yo Ho Yo!
Only suggestion, free drinks to forces!!

Tom Nolfi

August 19, 2007

Pauly, spent 5 days on the island, saw your show twice. Visited every bar in sight and none of them was like our evening with NY Pauly. Thanks for the laughs, and great job honoring the troops. Awesome job!!!

Jen

August 9, 2007

funniest key west moment......white guy walks up to my blacked out friend pratt and tries to spit some game at her and NY Pauly yells from stage "hey buddy your barking up the wrong tree" LOL too bad she doesn't remember that. your by far the best entertainer on the island. Me and my friends had a blast watching your show last wednesday, AND friday too!! def paid off being in the front row ....your music def made our trip we road all the way back to ft lauderdale listening to barnacle bill the sailor!!!!!!

chris

July 30, 2007

I was there when you crushed that guy from germany!!!!! Best entertainer i've ever seen!!!!!!! i live in utica, ny.....come do a show at the turning stone casino before you hit it big in vegas!!!!!!!!!

Ed Carter

July 30, 2007

Well my brother, the other night after our command picnic we brought about 20-30 peopl down to hear your show and some know what they were in for and some had no idea, by the end of the as usuall u "ROCKED THE FUCKING HOUSE" . DB and I will see this week

Mark

July 30, 2007

Bought your CD when down in Key West last week and I want my money back!!! Nah, only kidding.. Had a good laugh that night!
take it easy, and if it's easy, then take it again!

Sean Hessel

July 27, 2007

Had a great time down in Key West early July 2007. Went to some other bars but knowing was like watching you at Irish Kevin's. Bought the CD and my wife and I listen to it while sitting out by the pool. Our neighbors love you now.

METS FAN

July 6, 2007

When people ask me, "whats so special about NY PAULY" I tell them to see your show, it always makes me laugh hearing them singing your songs and repeating your show to other people the very next day. I think u say it best in your show, "thanks for the joy you have given me, we want u to know we believe in your song". Brother numbers dont lie,your crowds are large we love you dude! you rock! see u soon , keep the music flowing and the hotties moving.

Scott

July 6, 2007

My wife wondered why I thought Irish Kevins was such a great bar, so I took her there. We sat thru 2 of your shows and she 's already talking about heading back down there!

Juliet

June 30, 2007

Most memorable moment Oct '06: Moms and I go to Kevin's Irish Pub, get called out by NY Pauly for not shouting "Fuck," get excused to say "Freak," mom gets called a Milf, I end up as the Fair, Young Maiden, exchange singing for self-made Irish Jig, moms gets embarrassed next day on cruise ship as folks remember who I am from the night before. ...I actually think she was a little proud, heh heh. Thanks!

David Burston

June 29, 2007

Hey Pauly Me and Ed (Queens) are coming back to Key West July 21 we will be there for two weeks. L8R dude

Katie

June 26, 2007

Just saw you this weekend in Key West. You're fucking awesome!

lanemyr

June 26, 2007

You SUCK!

Tab

June 23, 2007

So I have a friend in Fort Liqourdale who is obsessed with you!! He found out I know you and now all he ever fricken talks about is how "kewl" NY Pauly is-lol...Take care sweetie. Hopefully I'll make it down again soon:)

Rock 'N Roly from Miami

June 21, 2007

Yooo... Paauly. It's Roly once again from Miami. I'm gonna be going down to Key West for the weekend and was hoping you'd be doing your thing at Irish Kevins. I'll definately come up and sing with you again if you're there. Had a great time last time... thanks for the memories!

-Rock 'N Roly.

David Burston

June 15, 2007

Pauly what's up brother? I'm D.B. the guy who always rolls with Ed Carter from NewYork(mets fan) Man I really appreciate the shows you put on stage, especially "Ring of Fire" Johnny Cash. I really hope that you can come to Ed's retirement I have been telling some folks there is a possibilty of you coming to Va many of them have been to your shows before. Take it easy bro. D.B. (the Canuck).

John and Heather Fox

June 14, 2007

We just finished vacationing in Key West, and we think that NY Pauly is the best entertainer we have ever seen.

Keith & Mary Swartwood

June 8, 2007

We Love you man!!! You make Irish Keivin's the best bar on Duval!!!

jill

May 22, 2007

You are one of the best Pauly...sincerely!

Steven Landsberg

May 22, 2007

Hey Buddy!! Hope all is well-Looks like you are doing great! Keep in touch!!

Landsberg
561-301-7119

Paul and Erin Hagen

May 21, 2007

My wife and I stumbled into Irish Kevin's last Friday...had a blast !!! especially when we mentioned we were from NJ and you told us to go F off....if you ever head back up north make sure you post it..we will be front and center.

THE cutest 21 and half year old in key west...lately

May 18, 2007

i luv ur site...hmm...what to say that everyone hasn't already said? well...you're the motherfuckingshit and you know it...your shows the most fun in kw...and well, ur dead sexy...only i hope i have more proof than most ;)
kisses from tennessee...lindsey

Catherine & Danny DaSilva from NJ

May 16, 2007

NY Paulie,
We just had to write and tell you how much we enjoyed your show. After going to Irish Kevins our first night in Key West, we somehow found ourselves there every night. You were fantastic! The best damn show in Key West. P.S. - yeah, yeah, Jersey says Fuck you too!!

The Fox Family from Michigan

May 11, 2007

Dear Pauly,
We had a great time at Irish Kevins because of your show. Thanks for all the songs and the laughter. You're a great entertainer!

Tab

May 4, 2007

Great website babe!:)

ed carter

May 3, 2007

Dude, as usual u "rocked the fucking house " when we were down there, were coming back middle of may and can't wait to drink and be just "shit faced pirates" with the key west's best entertainer. BTW how bout them "SKANKEE'S"

Scott

May 1, 2007

I was down there in April for my brothers bachelor party. We had a great time. Of course we caught your show alot. I spoke with you one night about your picture not being on the wall. Hopefully they have put u up by now.

Donnabella

April 11, 2007

Hey Pauly!!! Going to be back in the Keys again in a few weeks,....Me and my girlie friends are so looking forward to seeing your show again.!!! Cant wait!!!( Excellent new web site by the way! )

teacher3

April 5, 2007

saw you on my last night in Key West, had a blast! You were great. Can't wait to get back.

Sue-Ellen

March 16, 2007

Beautiful new website! I love it and YOU !!

ed carter

March 14, 2007

hey pauly,
i cant wait to get back to key west to see your show, i was there last year for 2 wks with the navy and will be back in april for 2 wks, btw i am the "fucking mets fan " cant wait to hear you again, and btw i still have the hat u signed and will be wearing it

Rock 'N Roly from Miami

March 12, 2007

Dude it was awesome taking the stage with you and singing La Bamba... you're lucky I fit the Miami stereotype and actually spoke spanish. Anyhow man... thank you so much for making our rive to Key West worth while. My girlfriend and I really needed the vacation, even if it was only for the day. We'll definately try to check you out again as soon as we can get a day off.

Rock on man... keep doin what you're doin!

-Rock 'N Roly.

nick norman

March 10, 2007

you're gay

Potato Head

March 8, 2007

Hey there! Havent spoke to you in years but heard you rockin the house. Any Seventeens or Seventy Ones...You THink?

Siber

March 7, 2007

Oh nice! Very pretty page!

Steve and Mary

March 3, 2007

You are awesome!!! We lived here two years now and catch you as often as possible. See you next time.

Kate

February 16, 2007

Just a quick note to say how much fun I had la-la-la-ing on stage with you last Saturday during Brown Eyed Girl. You're a great entertainer and will see you again next time I'm in Key West. I'll be listening to your cd during my 40 mile commute back and forth to work in the cold Michigan winter. Rock on!

Schmendrick from broadway

February 12, 2007

I was down from nyc.There is nothing in the city which comes close to your act. You made my weekend.

SKEETER THOMPSON

February 8, 2007

PAULY

MAN I JUST WANTED TO SHOOT YOU A EMAIL AND LET YOU KNOW YOU MADE MY LAST TRIP TO KEY WEST IN THE NAVY A MEMORABLE ONE I WILL BE BACK TO SLAM WHISKEY AND GUINESS 1.4 SECOND CHUG MAN WE ALL (NAVY GUYS) WILL FOREVER BE HAPPY PIRATES AND SINGING WHAT DO YA DO WITH A DRUNKIN SAILOR WITH YOU WILL NEVER BE FORGOTTEN ! THANK YOU MY FRIEND !! GOD BLESS AND IF YOU GET A CHANCE FIND ME A FAIR YOUNG MAIDEN TO SCREAM THE DELIGHTS OF BARNICLE BILL !! FAIR WINDS CAPTAIN
SKEETER

Jeremy Finch

February 2, 2007

I was at Irish Kevin's on saturday of last week. It was the best bar and most fun I have ever had. Your cd is great.

Bubz & Krista

January 30, 2007

My wife and I were in Key west for our honeymoon and you dragged me onstage for a Guiness chugging contest....before it was all over the crowd carried her around on their shoulders and she had to carry me home. Whiskey floaters are BADDD!! Made our trip.

tjg

January 24, 2007

Loved the shows in October! All the drunk girls made a run for Irish Kevin's 7 nights straight. Mostly to see you! Yeah, you're hot! :) Thanks for the Journey & yes, your Joker is the best! Great talking w/ you after the show. Can't wait to see the show again! The North Carolina party girls love you! :)

Gordon Feldkamp

January 20, 2007

Trish and I were down to see your show in November of 2006. It was the best time I have had for a long time. Hope to see you again next year.

Brad

December 23, 2006

Dude, this is "Cowboy Brad". I was @ Irish Kevin's the 1st weekend of Fantasy Fest where i sang tom Petty's ode to a commando way of life "Free Ballin'" and "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" You then stole my cowboy type hat and stunk it up the rest of the show! Thanks for the great memories...keep rockin'!!

Cheri Swain

December 12, 2006

You were great atIrish Kevin's last week. You made my work trip a lot of fun!

yourmama

December 1, 2006

Thinking about how proud I am of you and smilin'....but can they move Key West to New York????????

Donnabella

November 30, 2006

NY PAULY,...YOU DID IT AGAIN!!!! JUST GOT IN FROM THE KEYS LAST NIGHT,....HAD AN AWESOME TIME, AND YOUR STILL MY FAVORITE PERFORMER BY FAR!!!! KEEP KICKIN' ASS!!

Jacob Mehoff

November 20, 2006

Was on the strip this weekend.Your show is the best I've ever seen.Will be back!
Next page >>